Research Guidelines
This document outlines specific guidelines for researchers to follow in their writings. The intention keep things transparent, verifiable, high quality and trustable. A lot of our fellows are also high school students. We are not trying to to have perfect university-level academic rigor, we just want to write about important things the right way.
General Guidelines
- Privacy. Regardless of your type of paper, you can publish under your online pseudonym, rather then real life identity. As long as your peers and reviewers are actually identifiable, you can keep your offline self anonymous.
- Document file format. Researchers only need to make a .PDF or otherwise accessible document file format. Chlorine Systems will host a web page with an HTML version of your paper as well as provide a direct download link for the actual document file. Documents should also be equipped with proper metadata, such a publication date, related reviews and list of peer reviewers.
- Academic integrity. Paraphrase in your own words while retaining the source's original meaning, or use quotation marks for verbatim text. Presenting someone else's ideas, words, thoughts or work as your own without giving proper credit is plagiarism and strictly prohibited.
- Hedging & precision. Use clear qualifiers when appropiate. Use language such as: "the evidence suggests..." or "the results indicate..." rather than making absolute assertions unless proven unconditionally.
- General language. Keep the tone mature and academic, it is discouraged to use slang or otherwise unprofessional language in your writing. Also follow appropiate naming conventions for papers, don't call a 3 paragraph essay a treatise for example.
- Transparency. Be honest about who authored your work, inspired your work, or otherwise helped. You reap what you sow.
Research Papers Guidelines
- Use APA format. (7th edition) Every direct quote, specific statistic, or paraphrased idea from an outside source must have a corresponding in-text citation immediately following the material. Use a third-person or first-person active voice. E.g. "we tested..." rather than "it was tested..."
-
Open peer review process.
Chlorine Systems has a very open, transparent and consistent peer 6-step review process. Research papers must go through peer review.
- 1. Initial Screening: A peer checks whether the submission follows the Research Guidelines and has a clear argument.
- 2. Independent Review: Give your submission to at least 2 independent reviewers with relevant expertise who are not author(s) or close collaborators. Conflicts of interest or having otherwise biased reviewers is strictly prohibited. While it is flexible, it is heavily recommended to reach out to local scholars such as university students or staff to be reviewers. The language is only vague to cover our bases, such as reviewers who are non-accredited but otherwise important in their field.
- 3. Evaluation: Reviewers will give an evaluation, assessing originality, accuracy, argument quality, engagement with existing literature and clarity. Evaluative reviews must be substantive, transparent and always published publically. This is left a little vague so that way the evaluation can be structured around the paper rather then the other way around.
- 4. Editing: Reviewers thoughts and concerns from their reviews must be considered and integrated. At this point, Chlorine Systems fellows will also ensure if it has been critically evaluated enough. If it is determined there has not been a rigorous enough evaluation, more independent reviewers will be required.
- 5. Appealing & Disputes: Authors and Reviewers will sometimes have a disagreements. If it cannot be settled between them, authors or reviewers may appeal to Chlorine Systems. Chlorine Systems will delegate a trusted fellow to make a recommendation. If this fails or the disagreement persists, the author has to repeat step 2 and 3. We are in the process of creating an independent comission for this, but for now authors just have to "restart" peer review.
- 6. Publication: Final version is published. If appropiate, publish reviews and revisions alongside the final version. Peer reviewers should be named.
Note: Peer review does not make your paper correct, nor does it guarantee publication.
- IMRAD framework. Have a sections for your abstract, introoduction, literature review, methodology/approach, results, discussion, conclusion and then references. Formulate a strong research question first.
- Methodology & Reproducibility. If your paper is observing a natural phenomena there must be an extremely clear methodology and way to reproduce your results. Any quantitative claims also need clear mathematical proofs or methodological procedures that allows reviewers to also arrive at your quantitative data.
- Credible sourcing. Research papers must have credible sources. Recent, peer-reviewed journals are prefered, especially for statistics of scientific claims.
Note: If you are unfamiliar with APA format, there are several guides online for how to use APA format. You can also ask one of your peers for help.
Argumentative & Thereotical Papers Guidelines
- Use a format that fits the nature of the paper. IMRAD framework, MLA, APA are all valid options. A few paragraphs formatted in MLA may be optimal for a basic rebuttal or philosophical theory. A heavily structured APA document using the IMRAD framework may be more fitting for a more inquiring, questioning or observational paper. Seeking peer review is also recommended, but not required, depending on the nature of the paper.
- Credible sourcing. Recent, peer-reviewed journals are prefered for any statistical or scientific claim. Historical or theoretical references should instead be relevant to your argument. Primary sources are prefered for historical claims.
Reviews and Analysis
- Use a format that fits the nature of the review. IMRAD framework, MLA, APA are all valid options. Typically, reviews of other papers can be simple MLA essays, while a systematic review should follow the research paper guidelines
Artificial Intelligence Policy
- The use of LLMs are not prohibited as long as it's disclosed and transparent. However, you're still responsible for any code or research you submit. If information is incorrect, vague, or simply just slop that doesn't contribute to society, we will likely ignore it. If you repeatedly try to submit slop, you'll likely be banned from the fellowship after being given a few chances.
- Concrete definition of "slop." Slop is content without actual aim or curiosity, it is characterized by vagueness, low quality and little human oversight. We independently analyze everything that's submitted to us. Content that is unwanted, for any reason, we deny. Slop is the least desirable content for us.
- Disclosure. Be transparent about how you use LLMs. Disclose their usage in a disclaimer at the very top of your paper.
Ethics & Safety
-
Retraction & Corrections Policy.
If the document was also published inside an academic journal or university's journal, we'll follow whatever postpartum adjustments they employ. All previous revisions will still be archived (even if a paper is fully removed).
If Chlorine Systems is the only place the document was published then parts of the document may be retracted for the following reasons:
- Fabricated sources
- Data manipulation
- Other ethical violations
- Citation errors
- Typographical errors
- Legitimately accidental misquotes, misphrasings or other mistakes. (attempting to change wording to rationalize something post-hoc is strictly prohibited)
- Copyright issues.
- Legitimate public-interest concerns.
- At the request of the author(s).
- Human-subject and animal subject research. Human-subject and animal subject research is not published by Chlorine Systems and is far outside of the scope of the project.
- Loopholes, going against the spirit of the guidelines or operating in bad faith. We don't have a policy for every possible exception, we're a young organization trying to establish ourselves. We have a very low tolerance for pseudoscientific nonsense, word salad and bad faith actors.
Documents may be corrected for:
Documents may be removed for:
Legal & Misc
- Ownership. Chlorine Systems is not an academic journal, while we try to hold ourselves to academic standards, all research published are 100% owned by the author(s). Chlorine Systems only retains the rights to host, display, distribute and archive the document. If you'd like your writing to be removed, please contact us. If there are multiple authors, one author should be granted control over publication-status decisions beforehand. If nobody was selected to be given control over publication-status decisions, then it is automatically given to the main author or the author who contributed the most. This author is then responsible for the next person who has publication-status rights over the paper.
- Appeals for punishments. If you believe you were wrongfully punished, you can contact us.
- Other disputes. If there are any other disputes you'd like to resolve, you can contact us. Currently Chlorine manages most day-to-day management (including reading Emails), Chlorine is who can help with most things. If it is serious enough, you may want to contact the board of directors. See fellows. Chlorine is directly accountable to the other board members as well if Chlorine is who is in question. Board of directors is still be organized at the moment as we seek out official not-for-profit incorporation.
This is revision 1 of Chlorine Systems Research Guidelines, or CSRG. See CSRG revisions for older versions.