CSRG Revision 2 Peer Review Process
This document explains the peer review process that papers have to undergo to be published by Chlorine Systems.
Peer reviewer qualifications
A peer reviewer must demonstrate relevant expertise in the subject matter, methodology, or technical claims of the paper they are assigned to review. A reviewer must meet at least one of the following criteria:
- Relevant advanced degree: Hold an advanced degree in a field sufficiently related to the paper's subject matter to support a competent evaluation of its claims.
- Relevant research publications: Have published research relevant to the paper in a credible academic or scholarly publication independent of Chlorine Systems. Self-published work does not satisfy this criterion.
- Demonstrated professional or technical expertise: Possess substantial professional experience, specialized technical knowledge, or other demonstrable expertise relevant to the paper. For example, a forester with decades of relevant experience may be qualified to review a paper on forestry.
Meeting one of these criteria establishes eligibility for consideration as a reviewer but does not automatically qualify an individual to review every paper. The editor must determine that the reviewer has sufficient expertise to evaluate the specific submission.
Reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest and must be able to provide an independent, objective, and confidential assessment of the paper.
Process
- Reviewer Selection: The editor identifies at least two reviewers who meet the qualification requirements and have expertise relevant to the submitted paper. Reviewers may be recruited through local colleges and universities, academic networks, professional associations, or other relevant institutions.
- Conflict-of-Interest screening: Before accepting an assignment, reviewers must disclose potential conflicts of interest. The editor determines whether any disclosed conflict prevents the reviewer from participating. At this point reviewers are also given a private peer review guide.
- Public Peer Review: Peer review is conducted openly. The submitted manuscript and reviewer reports are publicly available on the Chlorine Systems website throughout the review process. Readers can follow the ongoing evaluation of the paper, including reviewers' critiques and subsequent manuscript revisions.
- Version History: Every version of a manuscript is preserved and remains publicly accessible, including earlier drafts and revisions made in response to peer review. This allows readers to trace the development of a paper and understand how its arguments, methods, and conclusions evolve throughout the review process.
- Editorial Decision: The editor considers the reviewers' assessments and determines whether the paper should be accepted, rejected, or returned for revision. Reviewers provide recommendations, but the editor retains responsibility for the final publication decision.
- Anonymity and Reviewer Disclosure: Authors may publish under pseudonyms and are not required to disclose their real-world identities publicly. Reviewers remain anonymous to authors during the review process. Upon publication of the paper, reviewer identities are disclosed publicly to establish accountability and transparency. Manuscripts, reviews, and version histories remain publicly accessible regardless of the editorial outcome.